Topper Copies

Discuss the potential impact of externalities on the assessment of welfare criteria. How do positive and negative externalities affect the efficiency and overall welfare?

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Externalities, as the name suggests, refers to those developments that are unintended or not actively pursued by economic agents for which they are not adequately penalized - in case of negative externalities or rewarded - in case of positive externalities.

Externalities lead to market failure as it leads to inefficient production or consumption allocation or both. Thus, pareto optimality condition is violated.

In case of positive externalities, market failure is observed due to under production of goods or services. For example consider services like education and investment whose expansion or increased expenditure creates positive effects socially

[a graph of price against quantity with marginal private benefit, marginal social benefit and demand curves, equilibrium points E1 and E2 and quantities Q1 and Q2]

As observed in the diagrams, expenditure on service like education creates marginal social benefits, due to which actual output should be at E_j, however, since social benefits are externalities and not accounted for, economy produces only D_[?] level of output, resulting in under production.

At the same time, in case of negative externalities like pollution due to industrial activities, social costs are created apart from private cost of production.

[a graph of price against quantity with marginal private cost, marginal social cost and demand curves, equilibrium points E1 and E2 and quantities Q1 and Q2]

As observed in the diagram, social costs, shifts the supply curve leftward. Thus, if accounted for negative externalities, economy should operate at E₂ level with Q₂ quantity. However, due to unaccounted social costs, economy produces Q₁ output and thus, over production is witnessed.

Therefore, externalities create problems of under or over production depending on type of externalities.