Topper Copies

The booklet attaches a question paper that does not print this question (candidate's second 5(b), written after 8(a)); the answer is written to the question of externalities, their effect on market efficiency and the Coase theorem as the remedy.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Externalities refer to the indirect effects of economic activities caused [?] inadvertantly. They may be positive or negative in nature depending on nature of effect.

For example → positive externalities are created when infrastructure like roads are created near factories, which ease movement for others also. Negative externalities example can be noise pollution cause from same factory during production

[a graph of P against Q with MPB=MSB sloping down, MPC and MSC sloping up with MSC above, intersections E1 and E2, prices P1, P2 and quantities Q1, Q2]

Externalities prevent markets from becoming efficient as they cause distortions between marginal private cost (MPC) and marginal social cost (MSC). As depicted in the diagram, any negative externalities when accounted for result in lower equilibrium quantity and higher price. However, since most of the times, these 'social costs' remain unaddressed, market efficiency is prevented.

To solve this problem of market inefficiencies, Coase theorem can be used to correct externalities.

Coase theorem provides a solution that allows for ways to correct an externality without government interventions through use of clearly defined property rights and low or minimal negotiation costs between different parties involved.

Coase theorem argues that the society can compensate the entrepreneur for losses incurred due to addressing externalities. In this process, society would still have net gains, since marginal social benefit is still greater than compensation to entrepreneur

[a graph of P against Q with MPB=MSB, MPC and MSC, and points E, S, P, R marked between Q2 and Q1 and between P1 and P2]

As depicted in the diagram ΔERP refers to costs incurred by entrepreneur to reduce production from Q1 to Q2 by accounting for externality, whereas ΔESRP(>ΔCRP) is marginal social benefit enjoyed by society due to reduced production. Hence, society can easily compensate the entrepreneur for its losses and still enjoy net gain.

However, a limitation of this theorem is that society may not always have well defined property rights or/and low negotiation costs. Therefore, government intervention becomes necessary in this regard.