Topper Copies

The booklet attaches a question paper that does not print this question (candidate's 7(b)); the answer is written to the question of the Wiseman-Peacock hypothesis on the growth of public expenditure.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Wiseman-Peacock Hypothesis deals with the growth of public expenditure over a period of time. According to this theory, increase in public expenditure happens in jerks and not gradually over time.

[a graph of expenditure in Rupees against time with three horizontal segments stepping up]

According to this theory, expenditure increases suddenly after an interval of time due to unexpected developments. As a result higher level of public expenditure is achieved via displacement effect. This higher public expenditure is achieved via higher taxation, and public in time achieves new tax tolerance with displacement effect.

However, this theory has its own limitations. These include:-

1. Theory posits that rise in public expenditure is due to unexpected developments however, higher expenditures are needed for growing populations, urbanization, development projects etc. 2. This theory also proposes eventual concentration of resources with the government with higher taxes and expenditures. This again is not true of modern economies and should also not be promoted. 3. Higher taxes is also met with higher resistance by the public. Therefore it cannot be said that simply public attains a new tax tolerance with rising expenses. Black marketing, tax evasions, smuggling etc. become rife with rising taxes as is explain also by laffer curve.

Besides this theory, Wagner's law also proposes that public expenditure increases with time. Although Wagner has not provided any explanation/reason for this phenomenon, there are many possible explanations:-

1. Rise in need for public amenities like sanitation, transportation, education etc 2. Growing populations and urbanization warrants a higher public expenditure. This is also demanded by the poor and marginalized sections of society specially.