The booklet attaches a question paper that does not print this question (candidate's 6(a)); the answer is written to the question of how the Pareto principle gives efficient allocation of two goods between two individuals, for two private goods and for a public and a private good.
Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025
According to Pareto principle of efficient allocation, optimal allocation is achieved when it is impossible to make someone better off without making anyone worse off.
(i) In case of allocation of two goods X and Y that are both private, between two individuals, we firstly draw a contract curve of consumption
[an Edgeworth box with diagonal "contract curve of consumption" through tangent indifference curves of A and B, and a utility possibility frontier on axes u(b) and u(a) touched at P by a straight "Iso value line"]
As observed in the above diagram contract curve of consumption is a locus of points where Indifference curves of A and B are tangent. Therefore, at every point of tangency:-
MRS_A = MRS_B
(Marginal rate of substitution = MRS)
Joining all the points gives the contract curve of consumption, which provides utility possibility frontier. Efficient allocation is achieved at point Q, where Iso-value line of X and Y is tangent to utility possibility frontier.
At Q → MRS_A = MRS_B = MRPT
MRS_A = MRS_B = P(Y)/P(X) (Price of Y / Price of X)
Hence, [?] of optimal efficiency is achieved at point Q.
(ii) In case of allocation of public good [?] (X) and private good (Y) between A and B, drawing of edgeworth box of [?] allocation for X and Y is not possible. This is because, due to non-rival [?] nature of public good, it is equally available for both A and B. Hence any allocation to A will not reduce availability for B in case of public good.
Therefore, actual allocation question pertains to only 'A' - private good.
In order to achieve pareto optimality for a single good, equal allocation is made of the good. For example, if 100 units of good Y are available, then equal allocation of 50 units is made to both A and B. This is because any deviation would lead to violation of pareto optimality. where with an equal allocation of 50 units to both A and B, it is impossible to change allocation to make someone better off without making other worse off