Describe the Kaldor-Hicks compensation criterion and how it differs from Pareto efficiency. What are its implications for evaluating policy changes?
Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025
According to Pareto efficiency model of welfare, any welfare activity should only be pursued upto a point where it is impossible to make anyone better off without making someone worse off.
Kaldor Hicks compensation model, found a way around this limitation by introducing the compensation principle. According to Kaldor-Hicks model any welfare activity which makes someone better off by making someone else worse off, if the winner or the gainer can compensate adequately the loser and even after paying the compensation is relatively better off than before. This way, an overall higher level of welfare is achieved in the economy, which earlier was not possible by following the pareto effiviency principle.
As observed in the diagram, if an economy of moves from point N to M therefore increasing welfare for Y from Y1 to Y2, it is still feasible to pursue this activity as Y can compensate to X for its loss by moving from M to Q and restoring X's original welfare, whilst still ultimately improving welfare level from Y1 to Y3.
[a graph of Y against X with a concave frontier carrying points M, Q and N, with Y1, Y2, Y3 marked on the Y axis and X2, X1 on the X axis]
However, Scitovsky pointed out that following Kaldor-Hicks compensation model would sometimes create contradictory and inconsistent results. This can be proved in the case of two intersecting utility frontiers.
[two intersecting utility possibility frontiers on axes U(A) and U(B), with points M and N marked]
Movement from M to N: Gainer B, Loser A, W(B) > W(A), compensation
Movement from N to M: Gainer A, Loser B, U(B) W(A) > W(B), compensation
In this particular situation movement from N to M and M to N is possible. This is known as Scitovsky paradox. Hence, it is not possible to determine what approach to take by following Kaldor-Hicks compensation model.
To counter this Scitovsky proposed a double criteria where it may be beneficial for moving from N to M, but reverse should be untrue. This is only possible in case of higher utility possibility frontier and hence, Scitovsky formula formulated a way to counter the paradox and conflicting results associated with Kaldor Hicks compensation model