Topper Copies

The booklet attaches a question paper that does not print this question (candidate's 3(b)); the answer is written to the question of Arrow's impossibility theorem.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Arrow's impossibility theorem elucidates how it is impossible to create a social welfare function that meets the following criteria based on ordinal preferences :-

- (a) Meets the reflexive, transitive property of individual welfare function while aggregating preferences to create a social welfare function - (b) Where preferences for certain consumption bundles remain unaffected with the introduction of a new variable

For example - If there are two goods X and Y consumed by two people 1 & 2 and their order of preference for goods is :-

| Person 1 | Person 2 | |---|---| | X (1) | Y (1) | | Y (2) | X (2) |

∴ Society is indifferent.

However, if with the introduction of a new variable Z, the preferences changes to :-

| Person 1 | Person 2 | |---|---| | X (1) | Y (1) | | Y (2) | Z (2) | | Z (3) | X (3) |

∴ Most preferred choice become 'Y'.

Hence, with the introduction of a new variable 'Z', overall preferences in the social welfare function also changed.

- (c) If the people in society prefer X to Y good, then social welfare function should also reflect that choice preference.

According to Arrow it is impossible to formulate a social ordering that meets all the three criteria without violating one of the below conditions :-

- (a) Non-dictatorship → Unless one violates the democratic principle where choice of everyone weighs equally, a decisive Social ordering cannot be achieved: - (b) Unrestricted domain → Social preference is gathered from all for all goods and hence, every good is ranked for consumption - (c) Pareto Efficiency → Impossible to make someone better off without making worse off should be the optimal condition for social welfare function - (d) Social order → voters or people should be able to assert their preferences in a connecting and transitive manner - (e) Independence of irrelevant alternatives which means Social ordering of different goods should not change due to addition of new variables/options/ alternatives

Therefore, creating a social welfare function based on ordinal ordering in a democratic society that meets transitive, reflexive, and individual preferences is impossible according to Arrow.