Topper Copies

(c) Compare and contrast the key assumptions and policy implications of neo-classical and neo-Keynesian economic theories.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Neo classical and Neo Keynesian economic theories emerged in 1970s after Keynes orthodoxy observed during stagflation amidst Supply side shocks.

Neoclassical framework was developed under adaptive expectations by Milton Friedman and Phelp , it was later modified by Lucas and rational expectation model

Key ASSUMPTIONS OF NEO CLASSICALS

1. self adjusting mechanism of economy and existence of full employment 2. Markets clears and labor demand equals labor supply at all time. Hence there is no Involuntary unemployment 3. wage Price flexibility Causes adjustments 4. Agents optimise where firms maximise their profits and individuals maximise their utility

POLICY IMPLICATIONS OF NEOCLASSICALS

1. Advocates non interventionist approach due to self-adjusting mechanism in long run. 2. In short run, monetary policy as form of 'monetary surprises' can cause output fluctuations but this will be short-lived 3. Any attempt in form of discretionary monetary policy can further destabilise the economy 4. Rules Based Monetary Policy as advocated by Friedman 5. Fiscal Policy entirely ineffective as rise in interest rate crowds out private investment

KEY ASSUMPTIONS OF NEO KEYNESIAN

1. Downward Price Rigidity 2. Sticky wages, hence labor market wont clear and there will be involuntary unemployment 3. Imperfect competition 4. Borrows assumption of rational expectation from neo classicals.

POLICY IMPLICATION

Neo Keynesian explain the sticky wages assumption based on various models →

1. Menu cost : Since revising menu cost would be higher, firms would not change prices and hence price rigidity 2. Insider outside model : Due to influence of insiders, wages would be higher than market clearing wage 3. Efficiency wage model where firms pay more than market clearing wage to ensure high productivity

Neo Keynesian advocated interventionist approach to address output fluctuations in form of fiscal Policy and Monetary Policy. They re-emphasised that monetary policy would not work during depression (liquidity trap) and advocated for fiscal stimulus. This has worked well in tackling 2008 Financial crisis across various economies.