(a) Compare the life-cycle hypothesis with Permanent income hypothesis. In what ways are they similar and different?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Lifecycle Hypothesis was given by Modigliani and Ando which states that person's consumption depends on income earned in entire lifecycle in contrast to what Keynes stated wrt current Income
[a graph of consumption against age, marked at 0, 25 and 65, with a curved consumption line above a slightly rising line d, the area between hatched and labelled savings and dissavings; Fig: Lifecycle Hypothesis]
Shaded area shows savings and dissavings out of Income and current consumption. CC → Consumption curve which slightly increases with rising age
As shown in figure, initial consumption is based on dissavings. After age of 25 years, person starts saving and till he reaches 65, he has saved enough to consume at almost same level after retirement age Hence, consumption is stable since it depends on lifecycle Income
[a graph with income Y_L on the vertical axis and C marked lower, and O, W_L and T_L on the horizontal axis; a taller rectangle from O to W_L at height Y_L labelled Savings and a lower rectangle at height C from W_L to T_L labelled Dissavings]
As per the hypothesis,
OT_L × OC = OW_L × OY_L
=> Consumption = (OW_L / OT_L) × Y_L
limitations -> 1. Assumes that person knows all his credit requirements, savings needed 2. Ignores role of wealth
Permanent Income Hypothesis was given by Friedman and it states that consumption depends on permanent Income and not on transitory Income like Bonus, lottery - He defines Permanent Income as expected value of future Income and current Income
[a graph of consumption against income with a steep line CLR through points A and B and two flatter lines CSR through A and B, income Y1 and Y2 marked; Fig: Friedman Permanent Income Hypothesis]
As shown in diagram, consumption in long run has a higher MPC than consumption in short run. As income increases from Y1 to Y2, Person's consumption will move from A to B and short run MPC would remain stable
It explains why high income individuals have a lower MPC due to positive transitory income whereas low income individuals have higher MPC due to negative Transitory income.