(a) Compare the Kaldor-hicks criterion with the pareto criterion in assessing changes in welfare due to a new policy.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Kaldor-Hicks compensation Principle is an improvement over Pareto Criterio as it resolves the indeterminacy of pareto optimality
As per compensation principle a policy would increase social welfare if gainers can compensate losers and still be better off (Kaldor) or losers cannot bribe gainers to not bring the policy change (Hicks)
COMPARISON WITH PARETO CRITERION
Pareto optimality criteria states that a policy would be efficient if it makes someone better off without making someone else worse off. However, it leads to indeterminacy
1. Infinite solutions on Contract curve 2. Indecisive when few are gainers and few are losers
[a utility possibility curve with B's utility on the vertical axis and A's utility on the horizontal axis, with points R and S on the curve and P inside it; fig: utility curve]
As per pareto criterions
- P → S would be optimal as both A and B are made better off - P → R is indeterminate as B is gaining while A loses
As per Kaldor Hicks
- P → R is optimal as B can still compensate A and be better off ats (hypothetical compensation is made)
However, Hicks kaldor principle gives rise to Scitovsky paradox in case of overlapping utility curves
[two overlapping utility curves with B's utility against A's utility, with points E and F on the outer curve and C and D on the other; Going from C to D means C > D (as F > D and C = F); Going from D to C means D > C]
However, this paradox has been resolved by Scitovsky himself by providing below conditions -
1. Reversal Test: Gainers can bribe losers but losers cannot bribe gainers 2. Hicks - Kaldor compensation principle
[two utility possibility curves with B's utility against A's utility, with P on the inner curve and Q on the outer curve]
P → Q Both conditions hold true, hence social welfare increases.
limitations with Hicks - Kaldor Criteria
1. Not a new social welfare criteria as it is built over Pareto criteria itself 2. compensation is merely hypothetical 3. Fails in case of overlapping utility 4. utility as parameter for welfare is flawed (Amartya Sen) 5. Includes Interpersonal comparisons as evaluation of gainers, losers is done