The real problem is not whether machines think, but whether men do
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
The real problem is not whether machines think, but whether men do
"If that which distinguishes man is ignored, we will have to suffer igonimy" - Thomas Pennant, English Biologist
Off it was churtled from the psyche of Protagoras, a man for whom all means and all ends ran into increasing man's pleasure; that all intelligence, all work, all speech all thought and all action is knit to serve 'man':
Homo mensura!
The 21st century colludes with Protagorian thinking. All technology, all economy and all polity is centred around 'man'. And, when this egoistical man centres his interest on 'himself' (in thought), this operation of the economy, polity, society and technology enters the realm of Darwinism where all faculties of cognition, attitude and behaviour align to achieve just one goal. Maximisation of 'pleasure' is that goal.
'Pleasure' or 'comfort' is the foundation of 'machine'. When the seeds of scientific endeavour were laid in the 16th century, the centrality of humanism drove all actions. Machines were evolved to satisfy 'pleasure' of wealth creation, aggregation. From Cartwright's powerloom to Watt's steam engine, all 'thinking' aligned towards furthering of a unilateral goal - 'increased pleasure' - and this singlitude started the problem via the 'means' of machines.
To this ethos, it must be pondered - what is the 'real' problem? The race towards making machines 'smart' or the 'maker'? What exactly does the 'thinking' entail? How exactly is the difference between machine's thinking and man's thinking manifestly different? If it is different, then why have men stopped thinking? Have they really stopped thinking or have they started thinking differently? And finally - whether man's 'thinking' is the reason for the problems we face? In tying it all up, whether the machine's thinking is more pragmatic for the man than his own thinking, also merits attention to unearth the 'igoniny' Pennant mentions.
In exploring the dimensions of 'thinking', one questions as to why we think? What is its importance? Thinking is a faculty of finding, of creation, of distinguishing right from wrong, of pondering the vissicitudes of life, of the problems and marvelling perils it sends our way.
Descartes, a rationalist philosopher, in this tryst with 'thinking', decided to unlearn all he knew. He unclogged his brain, a machine of remarkable complexity, and thought and thought..... and thought some more! In this process, he realised:
I think, therefore, I am!
Such is the enigma of 'thinking'. In its process, it brings to man's brain a 'mind'. This transformation of a brain to a mind is what distinguishes a 'Frankenstein' from a 'Frang Fanon'. While the brains of the likes of Frankenstein pave way for the 'monsters' of satanic aptitude, the emotive acumen of the 'Franz Fanon's' of the world bring revolutions for positive change in minds and polities.
This logic, objectivity and mechanistic 'thinking', in excess, furthers apathy and renders not just all man's creation dangerous, but makes him the 'weapon of mass destruction'. It makes him the real problem.
On the other hand, when man operates this 'logic' and 'mechanised thinking' with 'emotive acumen' of experience-based and conscience-approved 'thinking' - he moves towards, in fact transforms into, a human being. When Oskar Schindler, a Nazi-turned-humanist, underwent a similar change of heart, he focussed his energies of 'thinking' into building hospitals instead of horror-inducing concentration camps. But why are these 'exceptions' and not the norm'?
When one asks as to why men do not think but run behind outsourcing the only faculty that 'distinguishes' them - the answer is sordid. When Renaissance brought a heavy impetus on 'reason' and 'enlightenment', the hegemonic discourse ran towards 'scientific enquiry'. This was done at the cost of the ideal-based normative thinking of the time. As Gandhiji pointed out -
"machinery is like a snake chole."
"science without morality is a sin."
He captured the 'thinking' of the time, which had left behind moral and humane considerations to singularly run behind 'making the machine think.'
Michel Foucault furthers this argument when he talks about the tendency of 'homogenisation' of thinking' to effectuate stable and steady societies. Man is made to think like a programmable machine that is given specific targets, has no 'goals' or 'purpose' of its own' and lives a caged existence. All thought is fortified. The ashram system of life, the Shakespearian '7 stages of life' are all but 'norms' that effectively templatize 'thinking'. Thus, eventually makes man not think. When Frankenstein lost sight of his self, he stopped 'thinking' and 'contemplating', and outsourced his emotional outlet to 'The Monster', the machine. And that is where the real problem lay. Not only did this rationale, his thinking, stop. But so did the 'intelligence' of the Monster - a beguiling one at first.
In its beguiling 'intellectual prowess of 'thinking', the Monster symbolised the expression of man's inability to 'think' holistically. A parochialism of thought, birthed by 'conglomerates' of corporatism, as per Noam Chomsky, a renowned thinker, is a consequence of this.
A consumerist mindset, narrow definitions of 'success' and 'good life' are fed into the psyche of man. The downward flow model of 'thought prognosis' reflects upon 'injections of thinking' into a passive audience to elicit a powerful, immediate, uniform effect on the 'thinking process' for desirable results. The ban on Instagram by the Turkish government was said to be done to stop such 'infectious' and to 'liberate' thinking.
The 'igonimy' in the parochialism thus manifests variously. The 'self' confuses 'purpose' of life with ambition of job. Like a machine, a target to become an engineer or a bride is set - no thinking involved.
The society starts producing more Mahmuds of Ghazni of plunder and doom as compared to the Vera English's who have the courageous 'thinking' of standing up for nuclear deals in giants like General Electric.
The nation starts moving towards Mussolini's chauvinism and autarkic thinking over Radhakrishnan's Vivekananda's and Aurobindo's universalism.
In all this, man loses purposefulness, his social embeddedness, his 'fraternity' and becomes a 'One Dimensional Man', just as Henry Marcusse's premonition runs.
To overturn this 'One Dimension' to variegated, 'One must think!'. In his creation of the quantum computer, in his creation of Artificial Intelligence, he has invented archetypical aggregators.
The 'machine' - from assembly lines to computers, runs on an 'input-output' schema. Man absorbs the input, he does not have it entered. And because he absorbs, he is an 'efficient leader', while a machine can maximise itself to the level best of an 'administrator'. One achieves the target of administering National Rural Employment Scheme Direct Benefit Transfer, the other curates better schemes to provide holistic social security - a thinking man aided by a machine leads such transformations.
Perhaps, in that case, the problem does not lie in the 'distinguishing' of 'thinking', but a borrowing of the machine's best practice to create better practices via synergistic dynamism.
If Frankenstein were to borrow from 'The Monster's' objectivity, he may have rationally addressed this ammoral creativism. Had a synergy of man's 'thinking' aligned with 'machine's ability to simulate, the 'Monster Study' that left hundreds of children in the ruin of 'stuttering' would have been avoided.
Ergo, if man were to think before making the machine think, the world would manage to avert Pennant's igonimy and forge forward with thinking rationally, thinking wildly and thinking loudly! and conquer its well-rounded Galilean Eureka!'