Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question (question 8(a), as the candidate numbers it); the answer is written to the question of what collusive oligopoly is, with the cartel and price leadership models and the differences between them.

Aditi Chhaparia, AIR 97, 2024

Collusive Oligopoly are oligopoly models marked by implicit or explicit agreements about price-output relations with an attempt to avoid price war and maximise joint profit. Cartel and Price leadership are two types of collusive Oligopoly models.

Cartel In a cartel model, a central authority determines joint profit maximising output-price as well as quota for each firm. It may also have a predetermined profit sharing model.

[Fig 1: three graphs side by side for Firm A, Firm B and the cartel dividing, each with price P* against output; Firm A and Firm B show MC and AC with q*_a and q*_b, the cartel graph shows MC a+b, AR and MR with q*]

Equilibrium output is at MC_a+b = MR = MC_a + MC_b i.e. Similar to a multiplant monopolist -

Price leadership It occurs when a particular firm due to some special feature :- 1. dominant firm w.r.t. Market Share. 2. Lowest cost firm 3. Barometric firm with most goodwill or experience

acts a price leader and the other firms are bound to follow it. The price leader also needs to be able to 1. correctly predict market demand. 2. correctly predict supply response of other firms 3. Prevent any cheating or Non price competition by other firms.

Key Differences

| Cartel | Price leadership | |---|---| | 1) A central authority determines prices s.t. [MC_[?] MR] | 1) The leader determines prices for the market based on its own profit maximizing level. | | 2) Output quota is also determined by central authority s.t. [MC1 = MC2] and cost is minimized. | 2) Output is usually not explicitly determined and firms sell their own π maximizing output at determined price. | | 3) More Stable because firms want to maximize joint profits and avoid price war. | 3) Smaller/ follower firms dont have the capacity of price war, hence they follow the leader | | 4) Lesser Risk of Non price competition. | 4) more risk of Non price competition. |

Barometric Price leadership 1. Its not the least cost or most dominant firm. 2. Its the firm with most - goodwill & credibility in the market. - Foresight about market fluctuations and profitability - experience and knowledge of the market.

Hence, firms willingly decide to follow its price leadership in order to minimize its own [?] of market fluctuations and earn maximum return.