The booklet prints no question (question 6(c)); the answer is written to the question of what crowding out is and the factors affecting it, including the cases of full and of no crowding out.
Aditi Chhaparia, AIR 97, 2024
Crowding Out refers to fall in private investments due to rise in interest rate after in expansionary fiscal policy.
[Fig 1, Crowding Out: an IS-LM graph with upward-sloping LM, IS1 and IS2, equilibria e1 and e2, i1 and i2 and Y1 and Y2 marked; beside it a downward-sloping investment demand curve I-bar - bi with I2 and I1]
→ As government increases expenditure, Y increases, bringing money market in disequilibrium.
→ Due to rise in (KY) induced Md, interest rate increases to ↓ speculative demand for money and being both money and bond market in equilibrium.
→ At i2, private investments fall.
Factors affecting crowding out - slope of IS (1/k_ib) - slope of LM (k/h)
(i) Full crowding out It occurs in the classical case of vertical LM curve where Money market is interest rate independent and equilibrium is attained at only a unique level of Y.
[Fig 2: a graph with a vertical LM line and IS1 and IS2 shifting to the right, i1 and i2 on the vertical axis]
Here as Money market stays in equilibrium at k(PY*) = M/P its not possible to increase Y without increasing money supply. ∴ Full crowding out occurs.
Also when IS curve is horizontal, investments are infinitely elastic to change in interest rate an increase in interest crowds out investments completely
(ii) No Crowding Out a) Keynesian case of Liquidity trap
[Fig: 3, an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM at interest rate i_c labelled M/P and IS₁ shifting to IS₂, ΔY = ΔG/1-C written at the top]
Due to infinite speculative demand for money, an increase in Y does not decrease i due to being money market in equilibrium
b) Keynesian case of vertical IS.
[Fig 4: an IS-LM graph with vertical IS₁ and IS₂ shifting right and an upward-sloping LM, i₁ and i₂ on the vertical axis]
Investments are interest inelastic ∴ a rise in i₁ to i₂ does not decrease investments.