Topper Copies

State and explain the H-O theorem and factory-price equalisation theorem. Explain how the prevalence of Factor Intensity Reversal would result in the rejection of both theorems.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Hecksher Ohlin (H-O) Theorem :- It states that a nation specialises in production of and exports the good which uses its abundant factor intensively.

[Assumptions:-] 1. 2 x 2 x 2: Nations (1,2), factors (L,K), goods (X,Y) 2. Good-X is labour intensive while Y is capital intensive. 3. Nation - 1' is labour abundant while nation - 2 is capital abundant 4. Perfect competition, constant returns to scale. 5. same preferences in both nations

[The theorem's explanation] :-

[two graphs: Before trade, Y against X with two production possibility curves PPF1 and PPF2, an indifference curve IC1 and points A and B; After trade, two curves with a tangent price line, points A', B' and E and an indifference curve IC2 through E]

- Before trade, at autarky, relative price of X (Px/Py) is lesser in Nation 1 than nation - 2 . N1 produces at point A & N2 at point B. - After trade, N1 specialises in X & exports X to N2 . N2 specialises in Y & exports Y to N1 . N1 produces at A' & N2 at B'. Both consume at E, which shows higher welfare as it lies on higher IC (IC2). - Relative price equalises in both nations -

(H-O-S) Factor - Price Equalisation Theorem

H-O-S theorem says that relative & absolute factor prices equalise between trading nations -

[a graph of Px/Py against (k/z) with a rising curve, dashed guide lines and arrows, and a point (k/z)* on the horizontal axis]

- When Px/Py rises in N1, production of x rises & y falls. This raises labour's demand as x is labour-intensive. This leads to rise in relative wage (w/r) . - similarly, in N2, (w/r) falls & equals the equilibrium (w/r)* of N1 .

Thus, relative factor price equalises in both countries.

Factor Intensity Reversal - It is a situation when a good is labour intensive in labour-abundant country & capital-intensive in capital abundant country . - It is more likely when elasticity of substitution is higher .

[a boxed graph of K against L with rays (K/L)1 to (K/L)4, two crossing isoquants x and y, and price lines (Px/Py)1 and (Px/Py)2]

- In the above diagram, XX shows production curve of x & YY shows fact of Y. - At lower relative price at Nation - 1, (Px/Py)₁, (K/L)₁ of x is lesser than (K/L)₂ of Y. So x is labour - intensive in n-1 that is labour abundant Thus, nation - 1 specialises in X - Similarly, nation - 2 specialises in X too, since x is capital intensive in nation 2 [(K/L)₃ > (K/L)₄] - Both nations specialise in good - X, so there is no scope for trade. Thus H-O theorem & factor price equalisation are violated -