Mr. X is a billionaire businessman who heads a conglomerate engaged in insurance, energy generation and distribution, and manufacturing. Despite being globally known as a great philanthropist, he turned down a shareholder request seeking the disclosure of the conglomerate's actions on issues related to climate change as well as diversity and inclusion. Because of increased attention to climate and diversity issues, many leading firms have committed themselves to incorporate relevant considerations in their business strategies. Therefore, some industry-observors wonder if Mr. X is out of touch with the industry at large and have warned him that failing to address climate change issues puts his businesses under systemic risk. But, Mr. X maintained his vote against the disclosure proposal, while at the same time acknowledged the importance of both climate change and a diverse and inclusive work force. However, Mr. X believes that such ethical issues take secondary importance to maximising shareholder profit. (a) Discuss the importance of including climate change strategies and diversity and inclusion in a business organisation? (b) In your opinion, what matters more for a business organisation - socio-environmental concerns or shareholder profit? (c) How can the two above-mentioned issues be reconciled?
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
This case highlights the modern corporate value of profits above everything else which endangers not just the surroundings but also the company itself.
(a) Importance of climate change strategies
- Uphold Gandhian Trusteeship by using profits to give back to the society/world at large - Uphold the spirit of corporate responsibility → company is not distinct from the society or planet - Uphold the value of prudence by taking the right steps at the right time for sustainability
Importance of diversity & inclusion
- Make the workforce vibrant and uphold value of inclusivity - Increase innovation via diversity of opinion - Uphold the value of compassion in the private sphere - For equality of opportunity
(b) Shareholder profit or socio-environmental concerns
Merits of upholding profits only
- No diversion of money towards non-productive work - All money invested for shareholders returns → increase investment
However, this approach takes a short term individualistic view by considering a narrow view that company can exist without taking all stakeholder interests or distinct from the socio-environment. This calls for Buddha's madhyam marg approach balancing profit motive with large goal of sustainability by giving back to the society for long term profitability via collectivism as a value.
(c) Reconciling shareholder profit with socio-environment
1. Upholding spirit of corporate social responsibility by going even beyond the 2% mark — as by Tata or Infosys 2. Better planning to identify areas of investment. (Eg) A data analytics company can train people in MS-Excel as CSR → generate productive workforce 3. Upholding Kantian categorical imperative of man as an end in itself → do not resort to neuromarketing for unsustainable products 4. Balance shareholder profits with environmental benefits by investing in solarization, etc. which fetch tax benefits and even subsidy 5. Have hiring policy which balances the intake from various communities or genders for innovation & diversity
This will help reconcile profitability as a value with larger goal of SDG 13 to protect the environment and include all sections for SDG 10.