Topper Copies

The Harrod-Domar growth model states that a country 'growth rate of per capita income depends on its rate of savings, whereas the Solow growth model predict that a higher saving rate is incapable of leading to sustained long-run per-capita economic growth in the absence of technical progress. Explain these assertions.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Harrod - Domar model and Solow model differ in the impact of savings rate on growth due to different assumptions regarding returns to capital .

Harrod - Domar Model :-

Assumptions :- 1. constant returns to capital i.e. constant capital - output ratio (θ) 2. constant savings rate (s) 3. fixed proportion production function 4. Full employment in economy

The Model :- - As per Harrod - Domar Model, growth rate of output is an outcome of the process of capital - accumulation. - capital accumulation takes place due to savings. These savings out of output create capital . capital leads to growth in output. - Let savings rate be, α = S(t)/Y(t) - Let capital-output rate be, θ = K(t)/Y(t) - Now, capital-accumulation is given as:-

K(t+1) = K(t) - Depreciation + Investment- => K(t+1) = K(t) - δ K(t) + S(t) => θ·Y(t+1) = θ·Y(t) - δ θ Y(t) + α·Y(t) => θ [Y(t+1) - Y(t)] = Y(t) (α - δθ) => θ·[Y(t+1) - Y(t) / Y(t)] = α - δθ => θ·g = α - δθ => g = α/θ - δ

Here, g represents growth rate of output. Growth of per-capita output (g*) is obtained by reducing population growth rate from g ie g* = g - n => g* = α/θ - δ - n

Effect of rise in savings rate

when 's' rises, growth rate of per capita income (g*) rises too. This is because higher savings rate lead to more savings, which leads to more capital creation. Due to constant returns to capital, this leads to growth in output Thus, rate of savings has a "growth effect" in Harrod - Domar model.

Solow growth Model

Assumptions 1. Diminishing returns to capital. 2. growth rate of population & technology are zero each. 3. Flexible coefficient of production function.

[The Model] The steady state equilibrium in Solow Model is determined when growth in per-capital capital is 0. Δk = Investment – Depreciation Δk = s·f(k) – δk At steady state, Δk = 0 => s·f(k) = δk

[Effect of higher s]

[a graph of savings, depreciation against k with a straight line δk and two concave curves s1·f(k) and s2·f(k) meeting it at k1* and k2*]

When s rises from s1 to s2, at initial steady state (k1*), investment -> depreciation. This raises capital accumulation. But due to diminishing returns, ultimately new steady state is attained at k2* & growth is chocked off. Thus, savings rate has only level effect, no growth effect.