What is the net welfare loss due to the imposition of an export subsidy on a good? Demonstrate the impact of export subsidy on welfare with the aid of a diagram.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Export subsidy is a form of protection in international trade, where home country subsidises costs involved in export of a good, in order to boost export of domestic product. for example : India provides export subsidy on sugar.
Net welfare loss due to export subsidy Assumptions: 1. Two countries - Nation 1 & 2 2. Nation - 1 is exporter of good -X & nation - 2 is importer of good -X 3. Both countries are large in size.
The Model :- - Before subsidy, there is free trade. Equilibrium price is Pw, at which import demand (MD) and export supply (XS) are equal.
[two graphs: left, Nation -1 with P against X, D and S, price lines Ps and Pw and regions a to g; right, World - Market with XS and MD and price lines Ps, Pw and PB]
- After Nation -1 imposes subsidy, the internal price of good -X rises in Nation - 1 to Ps. But for Nation - 2, the buying price falls to PB. - Effect on welfare is as under:- - (a) consumer surplus falls by area (a+b) due to rise in internal price. - (b) Producer surplus rises by area (a+b+c) due to rise in internal price. - (c) government expenditure on subsidy is (b+c+d+e+f+g) area. - Net effect is shown as under :-
| Net Effect | | |---|---| | Consumer surplus | -(d+b) | | Producer surplus | (a+b+c) | | Govt Expenditure | -(b+c+d+e+f+g) | | Welfare Effect | -(b+d+e+f+g) |
Thus, net welfare loss is area b+d+e+f+g .
- Here, net loss is due to 3 different effects :- - (a) Area b :- shows consumption effect i.e. distortion in consumption due to change in price. - (b) Area d :- shows production effect i.e. distortion in production due to change in price. - (c) Area (e+f+g) :- shows loss due to fall in terms of trade (ToT). ToT falls because international price of good-X for Nation-2 fell to PB after subsidy.
Thus, export subsidy has a net-welfare loss on domestic economy.