Explain A.K. Sen's capability approach to economic development. Elucidate the difference between capability approach and utilitarianism.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Ak Sen capability approach is a social welfare function which aims to satisfy societal wants using freedom, Capabilities and wider choices
CAPABILITY APPROACH TO HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
1) uses Arrow Impossibility theorem by relaxing some restrictions like Independence of alternative variables (By adding context specific choices)
2) Focuses on adding liberty and Choices to maximise social welfare
3) Criticises Bergson Samuelson and other utility based social welfare function as they are based on Pre-existing capabilities
4) Introduces 5 types of freedom
a) uses non-utility based welfare function as considers utility or flawed concept
b) Higher capabilities formation using - - Education attainment (eg NEP 2020) - Health Improvements (eg Ayushman Bharat) - Job opportunities (eg Employment linked incentive) - Skilling of People (eg vocational Training)
He supports the idea that "rather than giving poor fish, teach him how to fish"
DIFFERENCE FROM UTILITARIANISM
The classical utilitarianism was propounded by Bentham, Pigou who focused on maximising sum of individual utilites
SWF = U1 + U2 + ---- + Un
Hence, it aims to achieve greatest good of all (i.e. universal basic income)
However, it has certain limitations:
i) It proposes an economic policy as better even if it makes rich richer and poor poorer ---> (not equitable)
ii) Depends on concept of utilities which was challenged by AK Sen
iii) Doesnot consider interpersonal comparisons as focus on total sum
iv) Can further inequality in society
AK Sen capability approach shows an improvement over classical social welfare functions and has relevance for developing economies like India with huge potential of demographic dividend