Topper Copies

Compare and contrast the loanable fund theory with the liquidity preference theory in explaining rate of interest determination.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

The classicals & keynes differ in their mode of interest rate determination.

Classical gave the Loanable Fund Theory of interest rate determination.

It states that interest rate is determined based on savings(S) & Investment(I) curve which are a function of interest rate (i)

[two small graphs with i on the vertical axis: an upward-sloping S line captioned positive function, and a downward-sloping I line captioned negative function]

The equilibrium interest rate is where S = I .

[a graph of S and I crossing at E with i* marked, S>I above and I>S below]

E is the pt. where the funds that Households are willing to supply is exactly equal to funds that firms require .

Keynes gave the liquidity Preference Theory

Keynes states that interest rate is determined based on Md & Ms. While Ms is exogenous, Md is for 3 purposes - transaction, precautionary & Speculative.

It is speculative Md that is inversely related to 'i', thereby giving downward sloping Md curve.

[a graph of a vertical Ms and a downward-sloping Md that turns horizontal at ic, with i* and ic marked]

Interest rate is determined where Md = Ms.

when i fall to critical level(ic), the Md is infinite & thus becomes horizontal.

| CLASSICAL Loanable Fund Theory | KEYNES Liquidity Preference Theory | |---|---| | (1) Interest rate is determined in capital market | (1) Interest rate is determined in money market | | (2) S & I are functions of i. S,I = f(i) | (2) S = f(Y), I = f(i) | | (3) 'i' doesn't affect AD and thus acts as line of defence | (3) 'i' affect AD through changes in Investment as I = f(i) ⇒ AD = C+I+G+NX | | (4) Doesn't explain Liquidity Trap situation | (4) In Liquidity Trap, 'i' becomes stable at ic & doesn't impact output & AD. |