Topper Copies

"Trade unions have a role in reducing the monopsonistic exploitation but not the monopolistic exploitation." Discuss.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Imperfection can either occur in Factor markets or Product markets. If it occurs in Product market, it gives rise to Monopolistic Exploitation (For instance, Reliance Jio). whereas if it occurs in both factor and product market, it gives rise to Monopsonistic exploitation ( For instance, coal mining in ASSAM)

WAGE DETERMINATION IN IMPERFECT MARKET

i) under Perfect competition, wage determination is based on marginal productivity and competitive Prices. Hence, it equals Value of marginal Product of labor (w = VMP_L)

ii) However, in case of monopoly or monopolistic, wage is below value of marginal Product Hence, it is called as labor exploitation

iii) Trade and labor unions Can Bargain to reduce the extent of exploitation

[a labour market graph of wage against labor with UMP, MRP, labor supply and Marginal Expense curves, wages w₀, w₁, w₂ and labor L₂, L₀]

Under Monopolistic competition, → Firms are wage takers → wage = MRP = W₀ → labor = L₀ Hence, W₀ = MRP < UMP

Under Monopsonistic competition, → Firms decide wage based on intersection of Marginal expense and MRP → wage = w₁ < MRP w₁ < MRP < UMP

Role of Trade unions

Due to role of trade unions in the Bargaining process where there is Single Buyer and Single seller, w₁ < wage < w₂ Hence, wage can never reach competitive wages (= wc)

Explanation: i) Since firms maximise their profits in monopolistic markets, and P>MC i.e. P>MR. Hence, w < UMP

ii) Despite Bargaining process, the level of exploitation can be reduced in Monopsonistic exploitation by increasing wages beyond w1 but it will still be lower than w2

Limitations

i) Not really an exploitation as consumers enjoy Product variety for which they are willing to pay a higher price

The amount of exploitation in wage market can be reduced by fixing minimum wage laws via government intervention (example: Minimum wages Act under labor codes).