Topper Copies

Compare and contrast the Fisher's equation of money and the Cambridge equation of money. Analyze the usefulness of these equations in understanding and managing monetary policy in the context of controlling inflation and promoting economic stability.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Fisher's equation of Money given by Irving Fisher and Cambridge equation of money given by Marshall & Pigou are classical theories of Money demand which have been widely accepted by keynes and later classical too

| FISHER EQUATION OF MONEY | CAMBRIDGE EQUATION OF MONEY | |---|---| | 1. Treats Money as medium of exchange as only used for Transactional Purpose | 1. Treats Money as medium of exchange and Store of value | | 2. Comes in 2 forms: MV = PT (T= Turnover) and MV = PY (PY = nominal Income) | 2. Money demand is proportion of nominal income held by individuals | | 3. Increase in Money Supply has Direct and equiproportionate impact on Price levels i.e. 10% increase in MS —— 10% Increase in Price | 3. Md = kPY, which depends on Institutional factors, Income and Price levels | | 4. Consider Velocity & Money as stable which depends on payment habits and other factors. Rise in Prices as "Too much money chasing too few goods" | 4. Increase in money supply leads to higher Spending on Goods. K (mathematically equals 1/V) is also considered stable | | 5. Mechanistic approach as Accounting method | 5. less Mechanistic and more Behavioral Hence, more Realistic |

[a graph of Md (money) against Py (Nominal Income), a straight line from the origin with angle marked 1/V]

[a graph of Prices against Income, a downward-sloping curve AD(Mo)] Rectangular hyperbola graph

USEFULNESS IN MONETARY POLICY AND INFLATION, ECONOMIC STABILITY

1. classical QTM is implicit aggregate demand in case of classical macroeconomics who proposes non-Interventionist approach 2. Hence, any change in Money Supply leads to change in Price levels

[a graph of Prices against Output with vertical AS at Y=Yf and AD(M0) shifting to AD(M1), price rising from P0 to P] Fig: Monetary Policy in case of Classicals (leads to Higher Prices)

3. As per classicals, Money is a veil which doesnot impact supply side factors hence money neutrality. But Money impacts AD (Aggregate demand) which impacts price levels 4. MV = PY => π = g_m - g_y Growth in money supply outpaces growth in output ------> Inflation. Hence, need for Rules based Monetary Policy 5. Cambridge approach was re formulated by Monetarists (Milton Friedman) who also stated that Inflation is everywhere monetary phenomenon

Despite challenges and limitations in QTM like Neglect of Interest rates , these equations have shaped the macro Economic foundation across all schools of thought in economics