Discuss the concept of collusive oligopoly and analyze the conditions under which collusion is more likely to occur among firms in an oligopolistic market. Evaluate the economic incentives and strategic considerations that influence firms' decisions to collude, and explain the potential benefits and drawbacks of collusion for both the colluding firms and the overall market.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Oligopolistic markets exhibit certain degree of uncertainty due to mutual interdependence among 'small' number of large firms. To reduce uncertainty and achieve stable profits, firms collude with each other.
COLLUSIVE OLIGOPOLY
Under collusion, firms cordinate their output and prices by acknowledging the mutual interdependence. This leads to formation of collusion, reduces uncertainty increases Joint Profits and deters entry of new firms.
CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH COLLUSION IS MORE LIKELY TO OCCUR
1. leadership model : when there is a leader firm who decides output and prices based on profit maximisation and others act as followers
leadership could be based on below:- - i) low cost leadership where leader firm enjoys cost advantage (eg Indigo Airline) - ii) Dominant leadership where leader firm has maximum market share and fringe firms exist with less market share (eg ultratech cement) - iii) Barometric leadership when firms follow leader due to its expertise in forecasting and past experiences (eg TATA Steel) 2. CARTEL FORMATION : This form of collusion takes when in case of similar size firms , hence output and price decisions are delegated to Central authority . It works like multiplant monopolist (eg OPEC for oil producers) 3. Bain Price limit : This form of collusion occurs in order to deter entry of new firms in the market Hence , Price is always set within limits and not for profit maximisation
ECONOMIC INCENTIVES THAT INFLUENCE FIRMS DECISION TO COLLUDE
1. In case of leadership collusion, there are benefits to Small firms as well as leader from
a) Small Firms - enjoy Supernormal Profits - Stability in Profits - Reduces uncertainty - Cannot compete with leader from any way - Capacity constraints due to small size
b) Leader Firm - Maximises own Profits - Enjoy large output share - Stability and Predictability - Avoids monopoly as rules might kick in if small firms leave the market
2. In case of Cartel, there is Joint Profit maximisation i.e MR = MC a+b = MCa = MCb
Benefits for overall market
1. More Consumer choices in case of differentiated Products 2. Better consumer services and Quality Improvements, cash backs & Rewards if firms compete under Non-Price Competition
Eg Amazon vs Flipkart discounts, Cashbacks
DRAWBACKS OF COLLUSION
1. Prices higher than Perfect Competition - hence loss of consumer surplus and not socially optimal output 2. Price wars if firms donot cooperate 3. High Incentive to cheat under collusion ——— unstable markets And Breakage of collusion 4. Prisoners' dilemma 5. Deters competition and entry of new firms
Collusive oligopoly stability depends on multiple factors at play as there are high incentives to undercut prices and gain market share hence causing loss of Total Profits