Topper Copies

"Explain the circumstances under which monetary and fiscal policy measures may be ineffective in stimulating economic growth or managing economic downturns. Discuss the potential limitations and challenges faced by policymakers in implementing these policies.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Monetary and Fiscal Policies are Interventions by Government to stimulate economic growth via multiplier process under keynesian approach

Ineffectiveness of Monetary Policy

Monetary Policy works via Increase in money supply which follow 2-step monetary policy transmission - 1. Interest Rate mechanism using liquidity Preference Theory - 2. Impact on Investment due to change in Interest Rates

Case I

[a graph of Interest Rates against Output with IS0 and LM0 shifting to LM1, LM flat at the liquidity trap] Fig 1

Under case of liquidity trap, Monetary Policy is Ineffective as people hold idle cash out of fear of capital loss. Hence, no change in interest rates and output (Fig 1)

Case II

[a graph of Prices against Output with a vertical AS and AD(Mo) shifting to A(M1)] Fig 2

under classical case where supply determined output remains unchanged up to increase in money supply (Y = Yf)

Ineffectiveness of Fiscal Policy

1. Classical case (vertical LM curve) The Money demand curve is completely insensitive to changes in interest rates, Hence Md = kPY (classical QTM) As a result, Fiscal policy leads to Crowding out ——— No change in output and employment

[a graph of Interest Rate against output with vertical LM at Y=Yf and IS(G0) shifting to IS(G1)] Fig. Vertical LM and Ineffective Fiscal Policy

2. Flexible Prices In this case, Since prices rise due to rise in Aggregate demand, Real money supply falls — LM curve shifts back

[a graph of Interest Rates against output with LM(M/P0) shifting left to LM(M/P1) and IS(G0) shifting to IS(G1)] Fig: Price Rise due to Fiscal expansion. LM shifts left due to fall in real money supply hence full crowding out

challenges faced by Policy makers due to monetary policy entails rise in Prices (Inflation always a Monetary Phenomenon) and Crowding out Private Investments