Differentiate between 'Crowding in" and "Crowding out" concept.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Crowding out refers to reduction in private investment due to increase in interest rates as a result of fiscal expansion On the other hand, crowding in refers to higher private investment due to fiscal expansion
CONCEPT OF CROWDING OUT
As a result of fiscal expansion, there is increase in Aggregate demand based on multiplier process of keynesian framework
i) Due to higher income, people put less cash to alternative uses like Buying Bonds. As a result, Bond prices fall and interest-rates rise
ii) Increase in interest rates leads to fall in Investment spending hence reducing the overall increase in output
However it has certain limitations 1. Assumes that there is full employment which leads to higher rates 2. If financed by printing money, there is zero Crowding out
[an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM and IS shifting from IS0 to IS1] Fig: Classical case of Full Crowding out (Fiscal Expansion)
[an IS-LM graph with upward-sloping LM, IS0 and IS1, output Y0 to Y1, arrow marked Crowding Out]
CONCEPT OF CROWDING IN
1. Due to government expenditure on Building Social overhead capital as prescribed by Hirschman unbalanced Growth theory → there can be rise in Direct Productive Assets (eg) PM Gati Shakti by India 2. In case of Big Push by Government which leads to coordinated and simultaneous investment in Interdependent sectors, there can be crowding in (eg) Capex Push of 10 lakh crore in Budget 2022 3. Critical minimum effort as proposed by Leibenstein can put country to path of development.
Hence, concept of Crowding out or crowding in depends on the Quality of Fiscal expansion and 'Animal Spirits'