4. (c) Critically examine the infant industry argument for trade protection. Is it still relevant for developing countries?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Infant Industry argument for trade protection was advised by Trade-pessimist economists like Prebisch-Singer, Nurkse, Myrdal and J. Bhagwati. It entails accruing protection to infant emerging industries due to wrong specialisation possibilities arising out of economies of scale
[a graph of prices against output with average cost curves AC_US and AC_India, P_I, P_US, Y_India and Y_US marked; Fig: Different stages of development amidst Trade]
As shown in figure, since India and USA are at different stages of development with USA accruing economies of scale has below implications: 1) India with lower output and higher prices can not compete with USA industries (P_India > P_USA)
2) Possibility of wrong Specialisation as despite having cost advantage in India, infant industries won't be able to specialise due to price advantage with USA
Relevance for Developing Nations
In the above case, imposing trade protection measures like tariff, quota would raise the internal prices of imports and opens up possibility for specialisation. (a) Strategic Trade Policy states that Selection of infant industries should be done such that benefits of trade accrue to world and leads to higher output (b) various sectors chosen under Production linked incentive shows comparative advantage of India in those sectors -> Toys -> Textile Hence, the argument holds importance even today provided that infant industries are defined wisely as protection could lead to inefficiencies