Answer the following questions in about 150 words each : 10 x 5 = 50 (c) Compare and contrast tariffs, quotas and subsidies as instrument of trade protection.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Various instruments of trade protection are used to restrict free trade which results in changes in Terms of Trade, changes in Consumer and Producer Surplus. Most of these trade barriers are justified on basis of Infant Industry Argument
1. Tariffs : These barriers are put on imports to create divergence between internal price of imports and external price of imports. As a result of import tariffs, - Increase in Producer Surplus - Decrease in consumer Surplus - Increase in government revenue - Overall effect is ambiguous
2. Quotas : These barriers are used to restrict the amount of import to be allowed. They lead to increase in internal prices and creation of Quota Rent
[a supply and demand graph of an import quota: curves S, S+B and D, prices P' and Pw, areas marked between the price lines]
- Consumer Surplus reduces - Production Surplus increases - Quota rent increased - overall net effect = loss of welfare due to production and distortion losses
Import quota is preferred over tariff as it is more predictable in nature
3. Subsidies: These are incentives provided to exporters to expand output of exports It leads to decrease in external prices and increase in internal prices
[a supply and demand graph of an export subsidy: curves S and D, prices Pg, Pw and Pw', subsidy marked between the price lines]
- Consumer Surplus decreases - Producer Surplus increases - loss of Government revenue
Effectiveness of these trade instruments depends on which sectors are provided protections (Strategic Trade Policy)