A nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility (at constant prices), thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output. However fiscal policy is fully effective in this case. Do you agree? Explain.
Vidhi, AIR 224, 2024
Mundell - Fleming model is based upon perfect capital mobility, which implies there will be inflows & outflows of capital till the return of capital equalises [i_H = i_F]
In Fixed exchange regimes exchange rate are not market driven & set-up by centralised authority
With fixed Exchange rate & perfect capital mobility, Monetary policy becomes ineffective.
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal line at i*, a downward-sloping IS, an upward-sloping LM and a dashed LM' to its right]
↑Ms => shift in LM curve towards right as a result interest rate falls resulting into capital outflows.
capital outflows will generate more demand for foreign currency, which is supplied by central bank & the initial increase in Money supply again decreases.
However, Fiscal policy is effective
[an IS-LM graph with i on the vertical axis and Y, Y' on the horizontal axis, LM and LM' upward-sloping, IS and IS' downward-sloping, and a horizontal line at the interest rate]
with expansionary fiscal policy IS curve will shift to IS', consequently interest rate will increase leading to more capital inflow, demand for domestic currency increases, to be supplied by central Bank leading to shift in LM → LM'. Again, external balance is achieved & output has increased. Hence fiscal policy is effective.