During post-independence era India assigned the role of ‘Commanding Height’s to the public undertakings. Should this policy be continued? Give reasons for your answer
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
The planners of nascent India chose to go for state-led industrialisation, by assigning commanding heights to PSUs. Nehru-Mahalanobis model (1956-61) and IPR (1956) effectuated this strategy.
This policy had several advantages, thus can be considered for continuance:-
1. Led to industrial growth of 8% p.a. between 1956-61, up from 0.8% p.a. between 1900-40. 2. Enabled unprecedented resource mobilisation - saving rate rose from 5% to 23% by 1970. 3. Gave a stimulus to stagnant economy and enabled a process of accelerated growth [P. Balakrishnan] 4. Led to regional-balance by setting industries in backward areas. eg SAIL plants in Bhilai, Bokaro. 5. Avoided concentration of wealth in few-hands - gini coefficient fell from 35% to 31%.
[a small bar chart "Fig: Inequality" of Gini, 35% in 1950 and 31% in 1970]
However, PSU - led growth showed signs of decay post 1965. Thus, its continuance is questionable:-
1. Profitability of PSUs fell to 7% in 1980, capital - output ratio declined to 8% [Nagaraj] 2. Inefficiency, red - tapism and rent - seeking creeped in PSUs that led to high cost - low economy production. [Bhagwati & Desai] 3. X - inefficiency & Baumol's cost - disease further lowered their effectiveness. 4. Govt. intervention affected business decisions & hampered functioning. [CAG report]
Thus, the present planning process needs for a "paradigm shift" away from PSU - led growth. It needs to focus on :-
1. Privatisation and decentralisation of key sectors like space, energy, defence, aircraft, etc. - eg INSPACE & Antrix for space sector. 2. Ease of doing business through second - generation factor reforms. 3. Enabling greater FDI for solving the country's dual gap between saving & investment. 4. Reducing govt's presence in strategic sectors like atomic energy, telecom, etc.
Minimum government, maximum governance needs to be followed to lead to synergistic development of public & private sector, in spirit of TEAM INDIA.