Topper Copies

"To what extent did import substitution industrialization (ISI) policies contribute to India's economic development during the 1950s and 1960s? Discuss its effectiveness and implications for industrial growth."

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Initial plans, especially the Nehru-Mahalanobis model laid importance on import-substitution industrialisation (ISI) i.e. restricting foreign import competition to promote domestic manufacturing.

Effectiveness of this ISI strategy

1. Industrial output grew at 8% p.a between 1956-61, this was a great boost over 0.8% pa. growth during 1900-1940 [Sivasubramanian] 2. Led to massive resource mobilisation through PSUs - that were held at commanding heights of economy. 3. Gave a momentum to the otherwise stagnant economy, thereby initiating the growth accelerator process [P. Balakrishnan] 4. Employment and income targets of capital sector (K) and consumer goods produced in factories (C1) were reached in first 2 FYPs. 5. Savings rate rose from 5% in 1950 to 23% by 1970 - creating investable surplus. 6. Target of growth of 1st FYP 2.6% and 2nd FYP 4.5% were achieved.

However, this ISI strategy started showing signs of fatigue by mid 1960s :-

1. The Industrial growth rate fell across all segments :-

| | 1950-65 | 1965-80 | |---|---|---| | Capital goods | 16% | 6.5% | | Primary goods | 11% | 4.5% | | Consumer goods | 4% | 4% | | Overall | 5.6% | 4.1% |

[source: Vijay Joshi (2016)] 2. Restrictive policies like MRTP, FERA and Industrial Disputes act prevented the growth of private sector. 3. Public sector GCF fell from 9% to 5% due to fall in profits of PSUs. [Nagaraj] 4. Licencing policy created inefficiency and led to a high cost - low productivity Industrial sector. [Hazari commission] 5. Reservations for SSI led to perverse Incentives, leading to dwarfisms, lack of economies of scale and missing middle [Rakesh Mohan]

Thus, ISI strategy led to inward orientation and structural. [?] as per [Raj Krishna], that was sought to be solved by liberalisation from 1980s.