(c) Discuss the challenges and achievements of land tenure reforms in post-independence India.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Land Tenure Reforms were initiated in 1950s with the aim to protect tenancy rights, abolish intermediaries and lead to greater agricultural production.
Challenges in land tenure reforms
1. Lack of well-documented land records made implementation of ceilings difficult. 2. Legal challenges in form of cases against amendments of constitution regarding Right to Property (Art 31) - led to Shankari Prasad, Golak Nath, etc. 3. Political will was lacking - that led to uneven implementation of the reforms across states [PS Appu] 4. Bureaucracy was neutral if not apathetic in implementation [Planning Commission - 1960 Report] 5. Loopholes in laws like ceiling in individual's name rather than family, large exemptions for personal cultivation led to poor implementation. 6. Only 4% tenants got occupational rights and 2% land consolidated [Appu] 7. Tenancy went underground, leading to 30% rise in landless labour [Hague Commission]
Achievements of land tenure system
1. Abolition of zamindary was successfully implemented - leading to fall in absentee ownership [P.S. Appu] 2. Rural wages rose by 20% between 1950 and 1990 due to greater demand for agricultural labourers [IFPRI] 3. Poverty reduction was seen in rural areas [Himanshu] 4. Voluntary efforts like Bhoodan and Gramdan were also launched to complement government's efforts. 5. Bengal and Kerala saw successful reforms- contributing (35%) & (20%) to Tenancy reforms & consolidation [P.S. Appu] 6. Investment in agriculture rose by (14%) between 1950 & 1990 due to direct ownership [Banerjee]
Committee on Agricultural Reforms (1964) calls land reforms an "unfinished task" in India. There is need for land-reforms 2.0 to realise true rural Transformation for Viksit Bharat by 2047.