(a) Discuss the extent to which MGNREGA has been successful in combating the problem of rural unemployment. Suggest measure to make it more effective.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
MGNREGA was introduced in 2005, as a policy to provide right to work for 100 days to unskilled rural adults. It is an important poverty alleviation scheme of govt.
Positive impact of NREGA in combating rural unemployment :-
1. World Bank - WDR remarked it as the biggest employment scheme that contributes to (1/3)rd of rural employment at cost of (0-3%) of GDP. 2. NREGA raised rural wages, thus reducing the problem of unpaid labour [RBI]
[two line graphs, agricultural wage and casual labour wage, 1990 to 2020, flat then rising steeply after 2005; (source : RBI) Fig: Rise in rural wage after NREGA]
3. By creating casual - non agriculture jobs, it reduced the disguised unemployment in agriculture [Sen]
However, the impact of NREGA in combating rural unemployment is limited by following factors:
1. Average number of work days is only 50 compared to promise of 100 days [RRI] 2. There is no link between job creation & skill development in workers [ILO-2008 Report] 3. IFPRI survey shows 70% respondents were unaware of its demand-driven nature. 4. Leakages and ghost beneficiaries lead to leakages upto 42%. [CAG] 5. Inequitable fund allocation - states with 60% rural poor get only 25% of NREGA funds.
Avenues to make NREGA more effective are :-
1. Raise the right to work to atleast 150 days [Parliamentary Committee] 2. Skilling, training of workers to improve their capability. 3. Form social audit state committees to give effect to the provisions of the act [CAG] social audit under 4. Direct Benefit Transfers can reduce leakages upto 78%, as shown by [?] study. 5. Adequate budgetary allocation to ensure demand-based work creation and timely payments.
These steps can help make MGNREGA the engine of rural growth & employment creation and lead to Gandhian objective of gram-swaraj for antyodaya.