Topper Copies

Both the marginal utility approach and the indifference curve approach yield the same equilibrium position for a rational consumer. Discuss the relative advantages of the indifference curve approach over the marginal utility approach.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Marginal utility Approach was given by Marshall, to find equilibrium consumption of an economic agent.

Assumptions :- 1. cardinal measurebility of utility. 2. Money's marginal utility remains constant. 3. Idependence of consumption goods (consumption of one agent doesn't impact utility)

Equilibrium :-

As per Equi-marginal principle, a consumer reaches equilibrium when the last rupee spent on each good yields same level of marginal utility across all goods

[two side-by-side boxed graphs: MUx/Px against x and MUy/Py against y, each a falling curve meeting the horizontal MUM line with a dotted drop to x* and y*]

ie. MUx/Px = MUy/Py = MUM

Here, MU_M = Marginal utility of money.

Indifference Curve Analysis was developed by Hicks - Allen. It uses IC curves & budget line to find equilibrium.

Assumptions :- 1. Ordinal measurability of utility; 2. Continuity - preference is defined over all bundles. 3. Monotonicity - More preferred over less. 4. Transitivity - If A preferred over B and B over C, then A is preferred over C.

Equilibrium :- when MRS = Px/Py

[a graph with X and Y axes: a downward-sloping budget line touched by a convex IC at point E]

ie, IC is tangent to budget line

Equivalence of the two approaches

Marginal utility Approach : MUx/Px = MUy/Py => MUx/MUy = Px/Py

IC Approach : MRS = Px/Py => MUx/MUy = Px/Py (∵ MRS = MUx/MUy)

Advantages of IC approach over marginal utility approach

1. Does not assume cardinal measurability of utility . 2. MUM is not constant, so income - effect can be considered . 3. Can explain giffen goods case, while marginal approach can't .

Samuelson's Revealed preference theory further improves upon IC - theory -