Topper Copies

Critically examine the different version of the "fooling" model as developed by Friedman and Phelps.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Friedman and Phelps gave the fooling model to show how imperfect information can affect the output in short run.

Friedman's Version of fooling Model

Assumes :- 1. Only workers have incomplete Infom information, while producers have perfect information. 2. Markets clear continuously – demand is equal to supply. 3. Price & wage flexibility

When government raises money supply, AD shifts right to AD₂. This raises price. So Labour demand also rises, Ld shifts right to Ld₂.

[two side-by-side graphs: left, P against Y with ASn(Pen), AS2(Pe2), AS1(Pe1), AD1(M1), AD2(M2) and output points Y1, Y2; right, w against L with L^Sn(Pen), L^S2(Pe2), L^S1(Pe1), L^d1(P1), L^d2(P2) and labour points L1, L2]

But workers can't see the rise in price. They are fooled to think that real wage has risen & supply more labour. This raises supply & output rises to Y2. But, soon workers realise that price has so risen and demand higher wage. Labour supply shifts left to L^S_2 and AS to AS2. This shift continues till Y & L return to their natural levels - Yn, Ln. Thus, as per Friedman, policy can be successful in short run, but not long run.

Phelp's Version of fooling Model

- In this version, both workers & producers are fooled. - workers think real wage has risen & supply more labour. - Producers think price of only their good has risen & thus produce more of that good.

Soon, both workers & producers realise their mistake and correct their expectations. This returns the output and employment to natural levels.

Criticism of the fooling models:-

1. No specific reason stated by Friedman for imperfect information only with workers & not the producers. 2. Workers are consumers of a broad basket of goods & keep track of their prices. 3. Central bank periodically releases inflation & price data for the economy. 4. Lucas criticised the assumption of adaptive expectations used by fooling model - where expectation is formed based on past data & the same errors is repeated over & over again.

Rational expectations model of New - Classicals solves these criticisms of the fooling Models.