Topper Copies

Describe the policy ineffectiveness proposition as articulated by Robert Lucas.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Robert Lucas gave the new-classical model that highlights the policy ineffectiveness proposition - a situation where government policy has no effect on the output and employment .

Assumptions of the model :- 1. Rational expectations by economic agents . 2. Markets clear - continuously - no involuntary unemployment . 3. Price and wage flexibility .

Policy ineffectiveness proposition:-

Let the government use an expansionary monetary policy - to raise money supply :- This shifts the AD right to AD₂ & Labour demand right to L^d₂ , due to rise in price

[two side-by-side graphs: left, P against Y with AS1(M^e1), AS2(M^e2), AD1(M1), AD2(M2) and Yn; right, W against L with L^S1(P^e1), L^S2(P^e2), L^d1(P1), L^d2(P2) and Ln]

But, as rational agents would already have expected expansionary monetary policy, they would know prices will rise. So labour will demand higher wage & labours supply shifts left to L^S_2(P^e_2) and AS left to AS₂. Thus, output and employment return to their natural levels. The policy does not succeed in raising output & employment. This shows policy - ineffectiveness.

Criticism of policy ineffectiveness

- Assuming central level of knowledge & information with economic agents to take rational decisions. - In reality, central banks do use monetary policy & government uses fiscal policy to effect output in short run. - Policy surprise can have the desired impact of raising output, as pointed by Lucas himself.

The new classicals have accepted the criticism of unrealistic level of information requirement and are working to solve this far part.