What are the main differences between Keynesian and Neo-Keynesian economics? How do Neo-Keynesian economists incorporate microeconomic foundations into their models?
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Neo - Keynesian economics emerged under Mankiw and Romer, to improve the Keynesian economics in the face of criticism by New Classicals, led by Lucas.
Main differences between the two:-
| Keynesian | Neo- Keynesian | |---|---| | 1. Developed by John Maynard Keynes, & in 1930s. | Developed by Mankiw & Romer, in 1980s - 1990s | | 2. focus on nominal rigidity only. | Both nominal + real rigidity explained | | 3. Uses wage rigidity only. | Uses both-price and wage rigidity | | 4. Assumes perfect competition in goods market. | Assumes imperfect competition in goods market. | | 5. Poor micro-economic foundations of the model. | Micro-economic foundation is improved upon. | | 6. Uses adaptive-expectations - which are backward looking | Shows involuntary unemployment as a result of decision of rational agents. |
Neo Keynesian economists incorporate micro-economic foundations into their models, in following ways:-
A) Mankiw's - Menu cost Model
- Assumption :- Imperfect competition in goods market. - when demand falls, the firm may not reduce price due to menu-costs, which include:- - (a) cost of publicising the change in price. - (b) Managerial cost of revenue and profit analysis. - (c) Possibility of a price -war. - The firm will except lesser profits at same price, because menu costs exceeds the benefit of price reduction. - This lowers the production & leads to lesser employment - thus causing involuntary unemployment-
B) Romer's Efficiency Wage Hypothesis
- Assumption :- Productivity of worker depends positively on real wage.
[a graph of wage against employment: falling L^d and rising NSC meet at W*, a vertical L^s line on the right, the stretch between marked Involuntary unemployment]
L^s : labour supply L^d : labour demand NSC : No shirking constraint-
NSC shows the level of efficiency wage needed to prevent the worker from shirking. It rises with fall in unemployment. Efficiency wage is set higher than equilibrium wage, leading to involuntary unemployment.
C) Insider - Outsider Model
- Assumption :- wage is set by insiders in labour market, with no regard for outsiders - After recession, there are lesser insiders in trade union, so they set a higher wage, thus leading to continued unemployment.
This is called HYSTERESIS was seen in EU post 2008 recession.
Thus, Neo-Keynesians improve micro-economic foundations & show unemployment as decision of rational economic agents.