Topper Copies

(e) What are the emerging issues raised by some states In India in the context of fiscal federalism? Express your view in this context.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Fiscal federalism refers the arrangement for collection, distribution and redistribution of tax proceeds between federating units of a federation.

[W.K. Singh Panel] delineated 3 principles of fiscal federalism – fiscal equivalence, decentralisation and principle of subsidiarity.

Emerging issues raised by some states in context of fiscal federalism :-

1. Demand for greater devolution upto (50%), rather than (41%) as per 15th Finance Commission. 2. Opposition to cess & surcharges – that have risen from (10%) of tax proceeds in 1990 to (20%) in 2020. 3. Demand for continuance of GST compensation cess beyond 5 years to maintain revenue neutrality. 4. Proposal to use 1971 population figures rather than 2011 population figures by Finance Commission 5. Demand to raise finance without permission from the centre. 6. Opposition to loss of tax -autonomy post GST implementation. 7. demand for timely disbursal of funds under centrally sponsored schemes. 8. Special category status demand by states like Bihar.

In my view, there is need to reduce share of cess & surcharges to enable greater divisible pool. further, there is need to establish Fiscal Council as suggested by N.K. Singh Panel for fiscal monitoring. Finance Commission, as the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism must act as platform to resolve the centre - state disputes for cooperative federalism.