Discuss the potential impact of externalities on the assessment of welfare criteria. How do positive and negative externalities affect the efficiency and overall welfare?
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Externality refers to the economic costs or benefits arising out of transaction, which are not compensated for explicitly by costs or payments.
eg Pollution released by a factory.
Potential impact of externality on welfare assessment:-
- Pareto optimality assumes perfect market condition, without any market imperfections. - But externalities create divergence between private and social costs and benefits, thus leading to sub-optimal allocations.
Positive Externality
It is an unintended benefit for which the producer of the benefit receives no payment .
eg bees from apiculture farm help in pollination of nearby orchard.
[a graph of cost, benefit against quantity: MSB above MPB falling, an upward line MC provision subsidy, dashed drops to q* and q̂ with the gap marked]
under - production q* : Equilibrium q̂ : Social optimum output
Marginal Social Benefit = Marginal Private Benefit + Marginal External Benefit ie: MSB = MPB + MEB
This leads to under-production, as shown by deficit of Q* & Q̂. Pigouvian subsidy to the seller can solve this problem & raise production to Q̂.
Negative Externality
Unintended cost for the producer doesn't bear a penalty
eg: steel factory releasing slag in river
[a graph of benefit, cost against Q: MB falling, MPC and MSC rising, MSC parallel to a dashed MPC + tax line, dashed drops to Q̂ and Q* with the gap labelled overproduction]
MSC = MPC + MEC Marginal social cost = Marginal private cost + Marginal External cost
This leads to overproduction of the good, (Q* - Q̂). Pigouvian tax can reduce production back to Q̂.