Topper Copies

What are the similarities and difference between the Fisherian and Cambridge version of the Quantity Theory of Money?

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Quantity Theory of Money shows the direct and equiproportional relationship between quantity of money and price in an economy.

Fisherian Version

MV = PY : Equation of exchange

Here: M = Money supply V = velocity of money P = Price level Y = Real Income

In short run, Y is constant, V also doesn't change as it depends on institutional factors like payment habits, ATM density, branch density, etc.

So, M V̄ = P Ȳ → This converts the equation of exchange into theory of price determination :-

P = M V̄ / Y

Thus quantity of money has direct & equi-proportional effect on price-level.

Cambridge Version - It sees money demand as a constant proportion of nominal income. Pigou, Marshall Md = kPY . [Here k: Cambridge constant].

At equilibrium in money market, Md = Ms => M = kPY

Similarities between fisherian & Cambridge version :-

1. Mathematically, both are equivalent. M = kPY => M·1/k = PY => M·V = PY , where V = 1/k . 2. Both assume Y is fixed in short run [Classical assumption] 3. Like V is constant in fisher's approach, k is constant in Cambridge Approach . 4. Both allow direct & equi-proportional relation between quantity of money & price-level.

Differences between the two:-

1. Demand for money is more explicit in cambridge version. 2. cambridge version more clearly explains the process of impact of money supply on price :- when Ms rises, people use excess cash to buy goods, so that k remains constant. But goods market has fixed supply, so increased demand raises price level.

Friedman further modified the classical QTM to account for Keynes's criticism by introducing the role of interest rates.