What is the role of the Bergson-Samuelson social welfare function in welfare economics? How does it address the issue of interpersonal comparisons of utility?
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Bergson- Samuelson social welfare function (SWF), when combined with the grand - utility frontier (GUF) helps to find the bliss-point of the economy. It is the point of maximum social welfare, subject to resource constraints.
Features of B-S function :-
1. It is based on explicit value judgement, ordinal comparision of utility 2. No single value-judement, but different types of value-judement can be used. 3. Interpersonal comparision of utility is undertaken. 4. shows social preference or utility curve of community.
Role of Bergson - Samuelson SWF :-
It is combined with GUPF to find bliss point :-
[a boxed graph with UB and UA axes: a concave GUPF and three convex indifference curves IC1, IC2, IC3, with the bliss point marked at the tangency of IC2 and the GUPF] Fig: Social welfare Maximisation
When Here, Grand utility Possibility Frontier (GUPF) shows pareto-efficient points. IC1 leads to lower welfare than IC2. IC3 is not achievable given resource constraints -
So, Bliss-point is reached at tangency of IC2 & GUPF. It ensures both - efficiency & welfare.
SWF also shows that society may prefer equit welfare over efficiency in some cases! - For instance, let there be monopoly. So points on contract curve 'cc' are only achievable. Where A & B lie on GUPF & thus show higher efficiency, society prefers 'C' - thus choosing welfare over efficiency.
[a graph with UB and UA axes: contract curve CC', a curve through points B and A, indifference curves IC1 and IC2] Fig: Monopoly case
Issue of interpersonal comparisons of utility. -
It involves comparing the utility of different individuals. It uses value judgements, which differs from society - to - society: Various value judgements give rise to different SWFs:-
1. Utilitarian SWF → [Bentham Mill] Welfare = UA + UB . General Form: W = α₁U₁ + α₂U₂ [a graph with UB and UA axes: a straight downward-sloping line] 2. Nietzschean SWF : Welfare depends on utility of most well off W = max [UA , UB] [a graph with UB and UA axes: a horizontal line meeting a vertical line in a right-angled step] 3. Minimax SWF : welfare depends on utility of most worse off. W = min [UA , UB] [a graph with UB and UA axes: an L-shaped curve] 4. Cobb - Douglas SWF :- W = A UA^α . UB^β . [a graph with UB and UA axes: a downward-sloping convex curve]
Thus, each society chooses a different SWF, as per its value-judgements.