Topper Copies

"Why have land reforms in India faced persistent challenges? Discuss the obstacles and their implications."

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Land reforms were initiated post independence to have equitable land distribution, raise agricultural production and lead to equity.

Obstacles in land reforms :-

1. Political apathy - lack of willingness to act against the landlords, who formed a powerful lobby. 2. Bureaucracy was also neutral, if not apathetic - implementing the reforms half - heartedly [Planning Commission, 2001 report] 3. Legal challenges - Starting from first amendment over Right to property (Art 31) to golaknath case, shankari Prasad, etc 4. Land records were not well - recorded - lack of data created difficulty to execute ceiling reforms.

Implications of these obstacles in land reforms:-

1. Poor implementation of land reforms- only 4% land ownership transferred and 2% land consolidated [PS Appu] 2. Regional variations : West Bengal + Kerala contributed to 35% of land transferred to tenants. 3. Tenancy went underground or tenants were dismissed - leading to 60% rise in landless labour [Hague] 4. Even the farmers who got land could not cultivate it due to lack of resources [Sen & Iyer]

Committee on Agrarian reforms calls land reforms as unfinished task in India. [Stiglitz] uses the case of East Asian Tigers to push for greater land reforms for growth in developing countries like India.