Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question (question 2(b), as the candidate numbers it); the answer is written to the question of whether a marginal income tax affects only nominal variables in the classical model, given the classical dichotomy.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

The classical model of income, output & employment is based on the 2 notions of 'Says law' & 'wage-price flexibility'. These 2 axioms form the basis for full employment equilibrium in the economy & classical dichotomy which states that nominal & real pricing processes work independently. Accordingly, any change in nominal variables will affect only the nominal variables & not real various like output, employment, etc.

Since Marginal income tax affect a labour supply which is a real variable, it will affect not only the nominal variables like nominal wage, prices. But the real variables like output & employment will also be remain affected.

Explanation through diagram

The basic assumption of classicals for Labour market is that there is no money illusion i.e. workers work based on real wages (W/P). Also, wages are fully flexible. In this backdrop, reduction in income tax rate would shift labour supply curve (SL) to the right.

[three linked graphs: a production function TP(Y) with Y₀ and Y'; a labour market with SL and DL crossing at E, W/P₀ and (W/P)₁; an AD-AS graph with a vertical AS shifting to AS' and a downward AD (MV), P₀ and P']

Initially, as S_L increases, the nominal wage rate falls & output rises to y' as the vertical AS curve shifts rightward to AS'. Since output is supply determined, rightward shift in AS will raise output to y'. Also, given the downward sloping AD curve, the increase in output to y' reduces price level to P'. This fall in nominal wage & price results in fall in real wage (w/p)_o to (w/p)_1.

This shows that changes in income tax rate brings about real changes in the economy.