Does government borrowing always crowd out private investment? Illustrate
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
crowding out means that when the government expenditure is financed through market borrowings, it increases the rate of interest, thereby preventing private sector from undertaking investment
partial crowding out [an IS-LM graph with an upward-sloping LM, a downward-sloping IS shifted to IS', i₀ and i₁, and Y₀, Y₁, Y₂ marked with the gap between Y₁ and Y₂ bracketed]
Extreme cases 1. Full crowding out - (a) when there is classical LM (vertical) [an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM and IS shifted to IS'] This is due to loanable fund theory which results in water very high rate of interest - (b) when IS is vertical ( b= ∞) [an IS-LM graph with a steep IS and a horizontal LM meeting at E] Thus, any increase in rate of interest results in full crowding out due to infinite interest elasticity of Investment 2. No crowding out - (a) Keynesian Liquidity Trap (horizontal LM) [an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM at i₀ and IS shifted to IS', E and E'] It doesn't any increase in govt doesn't crowd out investment because Md is horizontal curve. - (b) vertical IS ( b=0 ) [an IS-LM graph with vertical IS shifted to IS', an upward-sloping LM, E₁ and E₂, i₀ and i₁, Y₀ and Y₁] i₀ rises to i₁ but since interest elasticity of investment is zero, the output rises to Y₁ & is fully effective due to break down of 2nd stage of monetary transmission - (c) monetisation of deficit [an IS-LM graph with LM shifting to LM' and IS shifting right, E₀ and E₁ at the same i₀] The i remains constant at i₀ due to increase in Ms in economy. The input tax credit given by govt too results in fully effective F.P.