What do you mean by collusive oligopoly? Distinguish between cartel and price-leadership with respect to the determination of price and quantity. Write a note on barometric price-leadership model.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Collusive oligopoly is a case where oligopolist firms enter into an agreement to decide price and quantity. eg OPEC
Reasons for collusion :- - To reduce uncertainty, price wars, etc, - To maximise joint profit. - Gain bargaining power in market.
Cartel v/s Price leadership
Cartel - It means forming a group of firms who take joint decision on price & output through a central body. - eg. OPEC. - Price & output are determined as under:-
[three graphs, Firm-1, Firm-2 and Market: MC1 with point (a) and q1, MC2 with point (b) and q2, and the market with MR, MC and AR crossing and Q marked]
Here, MC1 = MC2 = MR Q = q1+q2.
* Problem:- Each firm has an incentive to cheat -> firm 1 can raise profit by area(a) & firm - 2 by area(b) if they raise production. This can lead to collapse of the cartel.
Price - leadership -> Here a leader - firm sets the price & other firms follow. -> It takes place when a firm is more powerful than others, while in cartel, all firms may have similar power.
* Forms of price - leadership :- a) Dominant - firm leadership b) Low cost firm leadership c) Barometric firm leadership
* Problem :- The dominant firm must also be low cost, otherwise it will have asymmetric power - more power to reduce price than to raise prices.
Barometric - firm leadership
In this model, a barometric - firm sets the price. It is a firm that has good reputation of predicting the trends of demand, market forces, etc.
[two graphs in a box: market with D and S crossing, and the barometric firm with MC, AR and MR, a dotted line down to q* and the price line meeting the P axis at p*]
Firm sets price at p* in above diagram,