Explain the concept of crowding out. Also explain the extreme cases with suitable diagrams: (i) Full crowding out (ii) No crowding out
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Crowding out is a situation when investment expenditure falls, when there is fiscal expansion. This happens due to the rise in interest rate.
AD = C + I↓ + G↑
The extent of crowding out depends on the slope of LM curve.
Partial crowding out (G2 > G1)
[an IS-LM graph with an upward-sloping LM, IS1 (G1) and IS2 (G2), points A and B, interest rates i1 and i2, and Y1, Y2 and Y3 on the Y axis, the span Y2 to Y3 labelled crowding out]
→ when govt spending rises, from G1 to G2, IS shifts right - from IS1 to IS2. → This raises the income => Money demand rises => at initial equilibrium A, there is interest rate rises from i₁ to i₂ ⇒ investment falls (I₁ to I₂).
⇒ rise in income is crowded out.
- Initially, ΔY = α_G · ΔG from Y₁ to Y₃ (α_G : multiplier) - But finally, Y rises lesser, from Y₁ to Y₂.
∴ Y₂ to Y₃ shows crowding out.
(i) Full crowding Out:-
Rise in G is completely compensated by fall in I, thus Y remains unchanged.
[an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM and IS₁ (G₁) and IS₂ (G₂), interest rates i₁ and i₂ marked]
This happens in case of classical LM, i.e. vertical LM. Here, interest elasticity of money demand is zero. So, when money demand rises due to higher income interest must rise very much to bring money market in equilibrium. This lowers the investment substantially & causes full crowding out -
(iii) No crowding Out :-
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM and IS1 (G1) and IS2 (G2)]
This is case of Keynesian LM -> horizontal LM -> Here interest-elasticity of money demand is infinite. So, rise in money demand due to rise in income does not cause interest rate to rise. Hence, investment does not fall at all. No crowding out happens.
In full crowding out, fiscal policy is ineffective while in no crowding out, fiscal policy is fully effective. It is a case of Liquidity trap -