What are the limitations of conventional monetary policy during a liquidity trap situation? Explain in detail.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Liquidity trap is a situation at very low interest rates, when speculative demand for money becomes almost perfectly elastic.
Reason for liquidity trap:-
At very low interest, money is almost universally preferred, Because, everyone expects Interest to rise to natural level, this will reduce present value of bonds & lead to capital loss.
Limitation of monetary policy:-
In liquidity trap, interest elasticity of money demand is infinite (i.e. h = ∞)
[a graph of i against Y with an LM curve that is flat at low i and then slopes upward]
LM curve: Money supply = Liquidity Preference => M/P = kY - hi => i = 1/h (kY - M/P) [k: income elasticity of money demand. h: interest elasticity of money demand]
slope of LM curve = k/h when h = ∞ → slope = 0 and LM curve is horizontal.
when money supply is raised :-
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM line, LM1 (M1) and LM2 (M2) with M1 < M2, crossing a downward-sloping IS at i* and y*]
People use the excess money to hold cash, rather than buying bond. So price of bond doesn't rise, Interest on bond doesn't fall => Monetary Policy Transmission fails.
Thus, Keynesians prefer expansionary fiscal policy in Recession
[a graph of a horizontal LM line crossed by IS1 and IS2, with the income rise from y1 to y2 marked]
During 2007-08 crisis, USA faced a liquidity crisis, it used fiscal policy to come out of it - ARRA → American Recovery & Reinvestment Act