Topper Copies

Why would a firm that incurs losses choose to produce rather than shut down? Use diagram to Explain.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

In short run, a firm can choose to produce rather than shut down if its price is greater than average variable cost. (P>AVC)

[a graph of P against Q with MC, AC, AVC and a horizontal MR line at p*, a dashed line down to Q*, and hatched areas A (between AC and p*) and B (below p*); caption: equilibrium price & quantity]

- In above diagram, we see, p* (equilibrium price) > AC => Loss = area (A) - But gap between AC & AVC shows fixed cost. (AFC) at quantity Q* : TFC = area (A + B)

Case 1: Firm shuts down :- - firm will face loss of TFC i.e. area (A + B). This is because fixed cost is already incurred, it does not depend on production.

Case 2: Firm produces

Equilibrium is reached when:- 1. MR = MC 2. MC cuts MR from below.

=> This leads to Q* quantity at price P*.

At equilibrium:- firms loss = TC-TR = Q* (AC - P*) = Area A

∵ loss of area A in Case 2 < loss of area (A+B) in case 1, thus, it is better for firm to continue production. This minimises the loss of the firm.

But if at equilibrium, P< AVC, then the firm has to shut down.