Topper Copies

Differentiate between “growth effect” and “level effect”. How changes in saving rate causes only level effect, while technological progress causes growth effect in Solow model? Explain

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Solow Model is a neo-classical model that explains how interaction of capital accumulation, labour growth and technological progress produces growth of output and per-capita output

Two effects mentioned in Solow model are:-

1. Growth Effect :- It means change in a parameter causes sustained growth in per-capita output (y.) 2. Level Effect :- It means change in a parameter changes the level of per-capita output, without altering long run growth.

[a graph with log y on the vertical axis and time on the horizontal axis: two roughly parallel upward-sloping lines A to B and C to D, and a steeper line E to F crossing both]

- Parallel shift of growth path from AB to CD shows level effect, while swivel of growth path from AB to EF shows growth effect.

Effect of savings rate (s)

Saving rate (s) impacts the level of capital accumulation. When s rises, capital stock rises. But due to assumption of diminishing returns to capital, the growth in capital is choked off. Output per capita reaches a new higher level and stays there.

[two graphs side by side: s·f(k) curves s1 and s2 against the line sk with k1 and k2 marked, and log y against t showing a flat line rising at t0 to a higher flat level labelled "Level effect"]

Fig: Effect of rise in saving rate

- When 's' rises to s2, at initial steady state capital stock (k1*), investment exceeds depreciation. This raises capital stock. But soon new steady state is reached at k2*. - Output per capita (y) rises due to rise in k, but stays constant thereafter. Thus, 's' has level effect.

Effect of technological progress

- Let the production function be ŷ = f(k̂) and saving be s.f(k̂). - Then, at steady-state, capital accumulation is zero, so investment equals break even investment.

i.e. Δk̂ = s.f(k̂) - (δ+n+g)k̂ = 0

⇒ s.f(k̂) = (δ+n+g) k̂

where k̂ shows capital per effective labour and 'g' is the rate of technological progress.

[a Solow graph with k̂ on the horizontal axis: a line (s+n+g)k̂, curves ŷ and s f(k̂), and k̂* marked]

Fig: steady state with technological progress

At steady state, k̂ is constant, so ŷ (output per effective labour) is also constant.

Now ŷ = constant (C)

=> y = (Y/EL) . E = ŷ . E

=> Δy/y = Δŷ/ŷ + ΔE/E = 0 + g

∴ Δy/y = g

Also, Y = y . L

=> ΔY/Y = Δy/y + ΔL/L

∴ ΔY/Y = n+g

Thus, due to technological progress, output grows at (n+g) & output-per capita grows at 'g'.

Thus, technological progress explains sustained growth in Solow Model.