“Trade benefits the factor that is specific to the export sector of each country but hurts the factor specific to the import- competing sectors, with ambiguous effects on mobile factors” Explain.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Specific trade model, propounded by Samuelson and Jhonson can explain the impact of trade on earning of factors within the country.
Assumptions
1. There are two goods - X and Y. 2. Production functions of x and y are x = f(L, K), Y = g(L, T) where labour is mobile factor and capital and terrain are specific factors
The Model
- Let the country have lower pre-trade relative price of X (Px/Py). So after trade it specialises in production of X and exports X. - This raises the domestic price of X relative to Y. ie (Px/Py) rises
[a labour market graph with vMPLx and vMPLy on the two vertical axes and labour on the horizontal axis, curves MPLx·P1 and MPLx·P2, wages w1 and w2 and employment L1 and L2 marked, and an arrow for ΔPx]
Fig: Effect of rise in (Px/Py)
- For simplicity, lets take Px to rise by ΔPx and Py remains constant. This shifts the VMPL curve (value of marginal productivity of labour) in X to right. - At new equilibrium, wage has risen from w1 to w2 and labour employed in good -X rises to L2
Impact of factor incomes is :-
1. capital (factor specific to export sector) → labour employed in x-sector rises but capital is constant, so marginal productivity of capital rises.
[a graph of marginal product against labour with a downward-sloping curve and the area under it marked "return to capital", with L1 and L2 on the labour axis]
As shown, when labour rises in good -X, part of total product accruing to capital rises. Thus, capital owners are benefited by trade -
2. Terrain (factor specific to import-sector) → as labour employed in good-Y falls, its marginal product rises. This reduces the share of total product accruing to terrain owners.
[a graph of marginal product against labour for good-Y with the area under the curve marked "Return to terrain", with L2' and L1' on the labour axis]
Thus, terrain owners are hurt by trade.
3. workers (Mobile factors)
Impact on workers is ambiguous as- - (a) Real Income with respect to good-X falls as rise in wage is less than rise in Px. - (b) Real Income with respect to good-Y rises as wage rises but Py is unchanged.
Thus, trade benefits the factor that is specific to the export sector but hurts the factors specific to the import sector, with ambiguous effects on mobile factors.
Real example of this effect is seen in U.S.A, where labour unions in sugar sector oppose free-trade and demand trade protection.