“The best strategy of development is the creation of imbalances.” Discuss the statement in the light of Indian experience.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Unbalanced growth theory by Singer and Hirschman argue for development of few strategic sectors of the economy that have forward and backward linkages to other sectors.
The focus is on SEESAW advance - where a chain of disequilibria leads towards growth.
- There can be two ways of unbalanced growth :-
[a graph with DPA on the vertical axis and SOC on the horizontal axis: a straight line of balanced growth through A, B and C, with a stepped path A - A' - B - B' - C and another path A - D - B - E - C]
fig. Unbalanced growth
1. Through excess of social overhead capital (SOC) → this includes infra, road & power sector. - A - A' - B - B' - C 2. Shortage of SOC → this includes investment in directly productive activities (DPAs). - Path A - D - B - E - C shows this way-
- Hirshman favours the second way through shortage of SOC as it is more compulsive and automatic.
Indian experience with unbalanced growth
- Post independence, due to lack of resources, India also opted for unbalanced growth. - 2nd FYP (Nehru - Mahalanobis Model) focused on heavy - industry sector through PSU, while consumer goods sector was left to private players, with lesser state focus - While this strategy helped create industrial base, it led to inefficiency and inflation due to shortage of consumer goods - (Vakil-Brahmanand)
Thus, while unbalanced growth is suitable in initial stages, later there must be transition to balanced growth, as South Korea