“There is a general deterioration in terms of trade of the developing countries vis-à-vis the developed countries.” Comment upon the statement in terms of Prebisch-Singer hypothesis.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Prebisch - Singer - Myrdal hypotheses postulates a secular decline in terms of trade of developing countries. They use this to oppose free - trade policies.
Reasons for secular decline in ToT:-
1. Exports of developing countries are primary goods - their demand is inelastic, whereas developed countries export finished goods whose demand is elastic. So, with rise in income, export demand of developing countries grows slower & thus price of its exports fall relative to imports. 2. Developing countries have weak trade unions, so rise in productivity of labour is reflected in lower prices, rather than higher wages. 3. Development of alternatives to primary goods exported by developing countries reduces its demand. eg synthetic fibre for cotton. 4. Primary exports are weather - dependent and thus can lead to larger fluctuations in prices eg India's agricultural exports.
Emperical evidence has however not validated this hypothesis. It found that :-
1. There was no secular fall in ToT of all developing countries- 2. Even if barter ToT fell, Income ToT was found to rise. 3. Rather than overall ToT, looking at individual product baskets is more important.
Thus, the hypothesis needs further research. Case of East Asian Tigers & China shows trade can benefit developing countries -