How does the concept of "support-led security" differ from "growth-mediated security" in poverty alleviation?
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Poverty in India is 21.9% as per Tendulkar Committee. Recent data like Niti Ayog's MPI shows it has fallen to 15%.
Two key strategies of poverty-alleviation are:-
A) Support - led security
- It focuses on direct support to the poor through income support measures and transfer of benefits. - Welfare schemes like PDS, NREGA, mid-day-meal are some examples. - It emphasises the direct-attack on poverty, rather than trickle-down from above. - Amartya Sen is a prominent supporter of this strategy. He gave the CAPABILITY APPROACH to raise freedoms of people.
B) growth - mediated strategy
- It evolved at Washington Consensus; focuses on trickle - down effect. - growth leads to job creation, income generation that acts to reduce poverty. - Also, growth increases the size of the pie that leads to more resources for redistribution. - Bhagwati and Desai are major proponents of this approach. - First three FYPs focused on this.
However, the slow pace of poverty reduction in developing countries inspite of high growth led to rejection of growth - mediated security. Vellani calls for a balance of both these approaches for faster poverty alleviation.